Many observers have been waiting to see whether and to what extent the FDIC will pursue claims against former directors and officers of banks that have failed during the current bank failure wave. So far, the FDIC has filed just a single suit, against former officers of a subsidiary of IndyMac.
However, on August 31, 2010, federal regulators filed a complaint in the Central District of California against 16 officer and directors of a failed financial institution – but the agency filing the lawsuit was not the FDIC and the failed institution was not a bank. Rather, the agency filing suit was the National Credit Union Administration, and the failed institution was a credit union, Western Corporate Federal Credit Union (or WesCorp) of San Dimas, California.
A copy of the NCUA’s complaint can be found here. A copy of the NCUA’s August 31, 2010 press release can be found here.
Prior to its closure, WesCorp had operated as a wholesale or corporate credit union, providing back office services to other credit unions. As reflected in the agency’s press release at the time, on March 20, 2009, the NCUA placed WesCorp in conservatorship. At the time, WesCorp had $23 billion in assets and 1,100 retail credit union members.
As reported in the Agency’s August 31 press release, the former directors and officers were originally sued in November 2009 in Los Angeles County Superior Court in action brought by seven WesCorp member credit unions. The NCUA intervened in that suit and sought leave to substitute the NCUA as the proper party plaintiff. The court granted the NCUA’s motion and to file an amended complaint by August 31. The NCUA’s complaint supersedes the initial complaint filed by the member credit unions.
The NCUA’s complaint alleges beginning in 2002, after Robert Siravo became the institution’s CEO, WesCorp embarked “an aggressive campaign” to grow, which was successful due to the institution’s reliance on borrowed funds to make investments in mortgage backed securities. While WesCorp grew, so did its borrowings, which eventually equaled over 30% of the institution’s assets. As the firm grew, so too did its exposure to exotic mortgage backed assets, particularly securities backed by Option ARM mortgages.
In 2009, WesCorp was forced to record $6.9 billion in losses, rendering the institution insolvent. About two-thirds of the losses were from Option ARM securities WesCorp purchased in 2006 and 2007.
In addition to allegations against all defendants alleging negligence and breach of fiduciary duty, the NCUA complaint also allege that Siravo and the former head of Human Resources manipulated their retirement accounts to make them more lucrative, resulting in over $4.4 million in overpayments, including an extra $2.3 million to Siravo.
One of the defendants in the case is William Cheney, who was a member of WesCorp’s board from May 2002 to February 2006. Cheney is currently the President of the CUNA, which is the credit union industry’s national trade association.
At the time that the NCUA took control of WesCorp, the institution was the largest of the corporate credit union. The credit union industry, along with the rest of the financial sector, had been suffering some turbulence over the last several years. The NCUA has closed 14 retail credit unions in 2010, and closed 12 retail credit unions in 2009. There were 7,554 federally insured credit unions as of December 31, 2009.
The Wall Street Journal’s September 2, 2010 article about the NCUA’s lawsuit can be found here.
Be Excellent to Each Other: San Dimas is not only the pre-conservatorship home of WesCorp. It is also the home of San Dimas High School, which is of course where Bill and Ted went to school in the most excellent 1989 movie, Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure. (I wonder if Bill and Ted went on to work at WesCorp after their high school graduation. Perhaps in the investment division.) I am sure that when Bill and Ted learned that WesCorp had been put into conservatorship, they said something like “Bogus. Heinous. Most non-triumphant.”
In honor of San Dimas High School and the school’s two most famous alums, here’s a video tribute to Bill and Ted, showing their history report at a San Dimas high school assembly: