In the current heated DExit debate over whether companies incorporated in Delaware should reincorporate elsewhere (usually Texas or Nevada), one factor often cited is the expense of litigating in Delaware, usually as a shorthand reference to a contention that plaintiffs’ counsel’s fee awards in Delaware’s court are out of control. This argument typically cites to a few recent cases in which the fees awarded unquestionably were large; recent academic studies have taken the argument further to contend that the fees awarded in some cases were excessive.
However, a more recent study, based on a comprehensive overview of all Delaware court fee awards in the last ten years, challenges the premise that fee awards are out of control; the study finds, rather, that fee awards generally have been within reasonable bounds, and argues that a very small number of outliers should not drive the analysis of the issues. The study concludes that Delaware’s flexible approach to fee awards provides the appropriate incentives for plaintiffs’ counsel and includes safeguards to protect against excessive fee awards. Perhaps most significant in light of the current controversy is the study’s authors’ finding that “we find no evidence that Delaware fees are systematically excessive.”Continue Reading But ARE Plaintiffs’ Counsel Fee Awards in Delaware Excessive?
In the following guest post, Stephen J. Choi, Jessica M. Erikson, and Adam C. Pritchard take a look at the plaintiffs’ attorney fee awards in “mega-settlements” in securities class action lawsuits. The authors ask the question whether the lawyers who lead these cases and negotiate the settlements are appropriately rewarded for their efforts. Choi is the Murray and Kathleen Bring Professor of Law at New York University School of Law. Erickson is Professor of Law & Associate Dean for Faculty Development at University of Richmond School of Law. Pritchard is the Frances and George Skestos Professor of Law at University of Michigan Law School. My thanks to the authors for allowing me to publish their article as a guest post on this site. I welcome guest post submissions from responsible authors on topics of interest to this blog’s readers. Please contact me directly if you would like to submit a guest post. Here is the authors’ article.