In the latest sign that coronavirus-related securities lawsuits are continuing to be filed, a plaintiff shareholder has filed a securities suit against a biotechnology company and two if its executives, alleging that the company drove up its share price by promoting its HIV-focused drug candidate as a treatment for COVID-19. Although the new complaint is similar in many respects to prior COVID-19-related securities lawsuits, it has several distinct features as well. A copy of the plaintiff’s complaint can be found here.
Continue Reading Biotech Company Hit with COVID-19-Related Securities Suit
Cornerstone Research: Large Settlements Increased Total and Average 2020 Securities Suit Settlements
The number of securities class action settlements increased only slightly in 2020 compared to 2019, but the aggregate total of all 2020 securities suit settlements doubled compared to the equivalent 2019 total, largely as a result of several “mega” settlements over $100 million, according to a March 17, 2021 report from Cornerstone Research. According to the report, which is entitled “Securities Class Action Settlements: 2020 Review and Analysis,” the average securities suit settlement in 2020 was larger than in 2019, but the median 2020 settlement decreased slightly compared to the 2019 median. Cornerstone Research’s March 17, 2021 press release can be found here and the report itself can be found here.
Continue Reading Cornerstone Research: Large Settlements Increased Total and Average 2020 Securities Suit Settlements
A Year of COVID-19-Related Securities Lawsuits
It was over a year ago – March 11, 2020, to be exact – that the World Health Organization declared the COVID-19 outbreak to be a pandemic. And it was also over a year ago – March 12, 2020, in fact – that the first of the coronavirus outbreak-related securities class action lawsuits were filed. Since that time, more than two dozen other coronavirus-related securities suits have also been filed. But while the pandemic related litigation has been an interesting phenomenon, a year into the development there are some interesting questions about the litigation. Such as, for example, why hasn’t there been more securities litigation related to the pandemic? In this post, I take a look at the litigation (so far) and try to answer a few of the questions.
Continue Reading A Year of COVID-19-Related Securities Lawsuits
Electric Engine Technology Company Hit with Post De-SPAC Merger Securities Suit
In the latest example of a company that recently merged into a publicly traded SPAC getting hit with a post de-SPAC transaction securities suit, electric vehicle technology company XL Fleet Corp. has sustained a securities class action lawsuit that names as defendants both directors and officers of the post-merger operating company and a former officer of the SPAC. As discussed below, the new lawsuit shares several features in common with many of the recent SPAC-related lawsuit filings. A copy of the March 8, 2021 lawsuit can be found here.
Continue Reading Electric Engine Technology Company Hit with Post De-SPAC Merger Securities Suit
Coronavirus-Related Securities Suit Against Royal Caribbean Voluntarily Dismissed
As the lawsuits have been coming in, we have been tracking the coronavirus outbreak-related litigation, with more than two dozen securities suits accounted for so far. But while the plaintiffs’ lawyers have proven willing to pursue pandemic-related securities suits, the track record so far for these kinds of suits has been decidedly mixed. In the latest sign of the mixed bag of results for plaintiffs’ lawyers on these kinds of suits, on February 25, 2021, the plaintiffs’ lawyers who initiated the coronavirus outbreak-related securities suit against Royal Caribbean Cruises entered a voluntary dismissal without prejudice with the court (here). As discussed below, this development may have significance for other potential cases as well as for cases that have already been filed.
Continue Reading Coronavirus-Related Securities Suit Against Royal Caribbean Voluntarily Dismissed
U.S. Securities Suit Filings Against Non-U.S. Companies Increased in 2020
One of the interesting things about the 2020 securities class action lawsuit filing numbers is that even though the overall number of securities suit filings went down in 2020, the number of securities class action lawsuits filed against non-U.S. companies actually increased during the year. The 2020 securities suit filings against non-U.S. companies are reviewed in detail in a new report from the Dechert law firm entitled “2020 Developments in U.S. Securities Fraud Class Actions Against Non-U.S. Issuers.” The March 8, 2021 report can be found here.
Continue Reading U.S. Securities Suit Filings Against Non-U.S. Companies Increased in 2020
Delaware Court Rejects D&O Insurers’ Uninsurability Defense
The D&O insurance coverage decisions are coming out of the Delaware courts so fast and furious these days that it is getting hard to keep up. Just days before the Delaware Supreme Court issued its high-profile opinion in the Dole Foods case (which I discussed in yesterday’s post), the Delaware Superior Court issued an opinion in the Sycamore Partners case. As may come as no surprise to many industry observers, is favorable to policyholders. The Superior Court held in the Sycamore Partners case that Delaware law applies to the question whether disgorgement or restitution of ill-gotten gains is uninsurable, and held further that as Delaware has no public policy that would prohibit the insurance, the so-called uninsurability defense does not preclude coverage for the amounts. While I have been critical of several recent Delaware court insurance coverage decisions, I have fewer concerns about the Sycamore Partners decision, as discussed below. A copy of the Superior Court’s February 26, 2021 decision can be found here.
Continue Reading Delaware Court Rejects D&O Insurers’ Uninsurability Defense
Del. Sup. Ct. Rules for Insureds in Long-Running Dole Foods D&O Insurance Coverage Dispute
In a development that undoubtedly will be discussed among D&O insurance professionals for months to come, the Delaware Supreme Court issued an opinion last week in the long-running Dole Foods insurance coverage battle. Many D&O insurance industry observers will not be surprised to learn that the Delaware Court’s opinion is favorable to policyholders. As discussed below, the opinion (and the many rulings in the court below in this dispute) may encourage insurers to consider possible policy wording revisions. A copy of the Delaware Supreme Court’s March 3, 2021 opinion can be found here.
Continue Reading Del. Sup. Ct. Rules for Insureds in Long-Running Dole Foods D&O Insurance Coverage Dispute
OPKO Health Hit with Board Diversity Lawsuit
Regular readers will recall that last summer and fall there was a series of lawsuits filed against the directors of several publicly traded companies that had no African Americans on their boards. For a time, it seemed as if this litigation outbreak had subsided, as no further lawsuits were filed after the end of September. However, the impression that this phenomenon had played itself out was dispelled in February, when a plaintiff shareholder filed yet another board diversity lawsuit against the directors of Micron Technology. Now, in the latest sign that the board diversity litigation movement may have even further to run, on March 5, 2020, a plaintiff shareholder filed yet another board diversity lawsuit, this time against Florida-based healthcare company, OPKO Health, Inc. The lawsuit against OPKO Health’s board can be found here.
Continue Reading OPKO Health Hit with Board Diversity Lawsuit
ISS Releases 2020 Top 100 Securities Class Action Lawsuit Settlements List
According to the latest annual report from ISS Securities Class Action Services, there were four securities class action settlements in 2020 that were large enough to make the firm’s list of the Top 100 U.S. Securities Class Action settlements. These four settlements took place in a year in which there were a total of 99 approved monetary securities class action settlements totaling $3.26 billion The details of the settlements included the four largest can be found in the ISS SCAS report entitled “The Top 100 U.S. Class Action Settlements of All-Time,” here.
Continue Reading ISS Releases 2020 Top 100 Securities Class Action Lawsuit Settlements List