On January 6, 2008, Cornerstone Research and the Stanford Law School Securities Class Action Clearinghouse released their report on the 2008 securities class action lawsuit filings entitled "2008: A Year in Review." The Report can be found here and the accompanying press release can be found here.


According to the Cornerstone Report, through December 15, 2008, there were 210 securities class action lawsuits filed in 2008, which represents an 18% increase over 2007 and an 80% increase over 2006. The Report also found that the 2008 filing levels represented a 9% increase over the average annual filing level of 192 for the 11 years ending in December 2007.


As discussed below, the Report’s analysis of the 2008 filing levels is consistent with my own previously released analysis, which can be found here.


Cornerstone’s release of its annual securities litigation report is a much-anticipated event, and this year’s Report does not disappoint. It contains a veritable treasure trove of detailed observations, including a multitude of complex comments about the magnitude of financial losses involved in securities cases over time. The Report also has a host of other detailed comments about the specifics of the 2008 filings.


The Report merits a thorough and comprehensive reading. I briefly summarize the Report’s findings below and follow with my own comments.


The Cornerstone Report’s Findings

The Report observes that the period of heightened filing activity began in the second half of 2007. The 317 filings during the last 18 months represent a 71 percent increase over the 185 filings during the preceding 18-month period.


The Report finds that the 2008 filing activity was "dominated by a wave of litigation against firms in the financial sector" and that "litigation against firms closest to the on-going subprime/liquidity."


The 2008 Report introduces a truly nifty innovation called the Securities Litigation Heat Map, which graphically shows how concentrated the 2008 securities filing activity was in the financial sector. Among other things, the Map shows that nearly a third of all large financial firms were named defendants in a securities class action in 2008.


The Heat Map also shows how over the years different sectors have been variously targeted in securities lawsuits.


The Heat Maps confirm what practitioners in this area have long known, which is the litigation activity is strongly driven by sectors slides and contagion effects, as a result of which over time industry alone has proven to be a very poor predictor of likely future securities litigation activity. Simply put, the plaintiffs lawyers simply move on to then next hot trend.


The Report also includes the annual analysis of what it calls Disclosure Dollar Losses (that is, market capitalization losses at the end of each class period). The Report finds that these losses for 2008 class actions totaled $227 billion, which is 48 percent more than 2007 and 75 percent more than the annual average for the 11 years ending in 2007, and also represents the highest level since 2000.


In its review of the status of database cases, the Report finds that of resolved cases, 41 percent were dismissed and 59 were settled. The majority of cases were resolved after the first ruling on the motion to dismiss but before the rulings on summary judgments. For class actions filed between 1996 and 2002 and resolved by the end of 2008, the median time to resolution was 33 months, the median time to settlement was 37 months, and the median time to dismissal was 25 months. The Report also concludes that class action with higher shareholder losses take longer to resolve.


The Report also notes that the percentage of cases involving Section 11 claims increased to its highest level in 2008. The Report also noted that with respect to alleged violations of GAAP, there has been a shift from allegations related to income line statements to allegations related to balance sheet components. The Report also notes that seven of the 192 companies named in class actions in 2008 subsequently filed for bankruptcy, compared to two out of 172 in 2007 (although five of the 2007 companies filed for bankruptcy in 2008).


The Number of 2008 Filings

The Report’s tally of 210 new securities filings through December 15, 2008 is essentially consistent with my own report’s conclusion (refer here) that there were 224 new securities lawsuits through December 31, 2008, as there were 13 new securities lawsuits filed after December 15 and before December 31. The 13 additional lawsuits I included in my tally but that were omitted from the Cornerstone Report account for virtually all of the difference between the two analyses.


The arrival of 13 new securities lawsuits in the last two weeks of the year is unusual, as December is usually a slower month for new filings. The late December influx was largely but not exclusively due to the flood of Madoff- related litigation.


Cornerstone’s Report’s cutoff at December 15 is significant in other respects as well. For example, the Report states that lawsuit filings dipped in the second half of the year, and even relies on the supposed second half decline as one of the grounds on which it suggests that financial sector securities lawsuit filings may diminish in 2009. The Report also devotes a great deal of effort to trying to reconcile this supposed second half decline with observations regarding stock market volatility.


However, when all of the lawsuits filed through year end are included, it turns out that filings actually increased in the second half of the year. Not only that, but as I pointed out in my report on the 2008 filings, the securities lawsuit filing levels in the fourth quarter 2008 and in December 2008 represent, respectively, the highest quarterly and monthly totals in over five years.


Projected 2009 Filing Trends

The Report contains no predictions regarding likely overall 2009 filing levels, but the accompanying press release quotes Stanford Law Professor Joseph Grundfest to the effect that securities litigation against the financial sector may decline in 2009 because "virtually all the major financial services firms have already been sued," as a result of which "the pool of major financial services defendants might be getting fished out." In support of this conclusion, the Report among other things cites the fact that of the 15 largest financial services companies by market capitalization at the beginning of 2007, 12 of them have already been sued.


Professor Grundfest does not actually predict that overall securities lawsuit filings will decline in 2009; however, in the press release, he is quoted as saying that, because all of the major financial institutions have already been sued, "the supply of new defendants might be drying up." He also suggests that "litigation activity against the financial sector may decline next year," and in the Report adds that "it is unclear as to whether the wave of litigation will extend significantly beyond the larges financial firms in the near future."


My own view is that 2009 could well be a very active year for securities litigation. This view is based in part on the surge of litigation in the latter part of 2008, which shows every sign of continuing. The fact that there were thirty new securities class action lawsuits in December 2008, including ten new credit crisis-related lawsuits, strongly suggests that plaintiffs’ lawyers are finding no shortage of targets.


In addition, the credit crisis litigation wave long ago ceased to be just about the large financial institutions, if indeed it ever was just about that. As time has gone by, the wave has continued to spread and evolve. One attribute of this evolution is that as 2008 progressed, the credit crisis litigation has extended far beyond the financial services sector, as I noted most recently here.


In other words, the plaintiffs’ lawyers may or may not find new targets in the financial sector. (Although I strongly suspect that as a result of the Madoff scandal the plaintiffs’ lawyers will find innumerable new financial sector targets, but that is a separate issue.) The likeliest scenario, borne out by filing patterns that are already emerging, is that the plaintiffs will simply move on to other sectors, as they have numerous times in the past.


I note parenthetically that the probable movement of the litigation to a new sector is graphically foreshadowed by the Cornerstone Report’s Securities Litigation Heat Maps, which vividly show how quickly plaintiffs’ lawyers have moved from sector to sector in the past.


All of which I believe suggests that the heightened filing levels show every likelihood of continuing into 2009. Indeed, given the strong likelihood of additional Madoff victim litigation, as well as the likely continued spread of the credit crisis litigation wave outside the financial sector, the likeliest possibility is that 2009 will be a very active year for securities litigation.


The WSJ.com Law Blog has a January 5, 2009 post (here) discussing the 2008 securities lawsuit filings and quoting both from the Cornerstone Report and from my analysis of the 2008 filings.